This is a reprint of Mitch Alboms column from the Detroit Free Press dated September 13, 2009. In it he sums up what I have been saying for about 10 years now, and he does it better than I could. Enjoy!
Yell at Obama a new low but not the last
It was just two words.
"You lie!"
Two words. Not even curse words. But the where and the when made those two words significant.
"You lie!" It was screamed from the floor of Congress, by an elected official of the state of South Carolina, and aimed at the president of the United States.
"You lie!"
In the history of American politics, no one could recall a similar act. Not with all the fudged truths that have been told by American presidents. Not with George W. Bush and the Iraq war, not with Bill Clinton and his private life, not with Ronald Reagan and Iran-contra, not with Richard Nixon and Watergate.
Yet somehow last week, during a speech on, of all things, health care, Joe Wilson, a Republican congressman, was unable to control himself. He yelled those two words loudly enough to be heard in the chamber, on national TV and around the world.
And in so doing, he lowered the bar of American behavior another few feet.
Never mind that Wilson was incorrect. The president had said that under his health care bill, the benefits would not apply to illegal immigrants -- and they would not. The bills before Congress declare that. You could argue that illegal immigrants still could buy insurance or sneak through, but that hardly supports a liar charge, does it?
Never mind that. Never mind that Wilson apologized that night.
Something bigger was at work.
A culture of confrontation
Hate breeds hate, anger breeds anger, and I have been arguing in this space for years now that the American discourse -- fueled by the Internet, talk radio and cable TV -- has turned so mean it has nowhere to go but get meaner. Little wonder that immediately after Wilson's unforgivable outburst, it was being justified by certain Republicans not because it was correct, but because Democrats had been equally insulting to Bush.
Hate breeds hate, and there is money and fame in yelling louder and angrier. You don't get on TV by asking thoughtful questions at a town hall meeting, but you sure can get there if you curse, holler and scream like a captured banshee. Come to think of it, that applies to TV hosts as well.
Is it any surprise such behavior eventually finds its way into a room with the president? We were abhorred when an Iraqi journalist threw his shoes at Bush. We called it barbaric, typical of a country hopelessly behind us on the civility scale.
Where does Wilson rank on that scale?
Clearly near the bottom. But why did he yell those two words? Why did that speech and this president cause a veteran politician like Wilson to lose control?
The right to actually lead
I have a theory. For all the fawning popularity Barack Obama enjoys in certain circles, he is equally vilified in others. Those who don't like him truly don't like him. And there seems to be an element in this country that doesn't want to accept him as the president. From the kooks hollering about his birth certificate to the paranoids insisting he is a closet Muslim, there are people who just don't want this guy in that office.
The fact that he is half-black is not wasted on them, either. Let's be blunt. Nobody can use the N-word in public anymore. But they can use socialist, anarchist, alien.
And somehow it's now acceptable to deem a guy who has been in office barely eight months unfit and unworthy. It's acceptable to suggest he's taking us straight to hell. It's acceptable to yell "You lie!" at the commander in chief in a place where it has never been yelled before.
Hate breeds hate. Two days ago, I boarded a plane heading for New York City. As we descended over the Manhattan skyline, I realized it was Sept. 11. I thought back to the emotions that followed that day eight years ago, a feeling of unity, a feeling a patriotism, a feeling that no enemy, no matter how evil or determined, could ever tear us apart.
The enemy doesn't have to. The way we are going, we'll do it ourselves.
For tickets to Mitch Albom's charity book launch for "Have a Little Faith" on Sept. 30 at the Fox Theatre, call 800-745-3000 or go to ticketmaster.com. Contact MITCH ALBOM: 313-223-4581 or malbom@freepress.com.
http://www.freep.com/article/20090913/COL01/909130431/1318/-You-lie---a-new-low--but-not-the-last&template=fullarticle
Yell at Obama a new low but not the last
It was just two words.
"You lie!"
Two words. Not even curse words. But the where and the when made those two words significant.
"You lie!" It was screamed from the floor of Congress, by an elected official of the state of South Carolina, and aimed at the president of the United States.
"You lie!"
In the history of American politics, no one could recall a similar act. Not with all the fudged truths that have been told by American presidents. Not with George W. Bush and the Iraq war, not with Bill Clinton and his private life, not with Ronald Reagan and Iran-contra, not with Richard Nixon and Watergate.
Yet somehow last week, during a speech on, of all things, health care, Joe Wilson, a Republican congressman, was unable to control himself. He yelled those two words loudly enough to be heard in the chamber, on national TV and around the world.
And in so doing, he lowered the bar of American behavior another few feet.
Never mind that Wilson was incorrect. The president had said that under his health care bill, the benefits would not apply to illegal immigrants -- and they would not. The bills before Congress declare that. You could argue that illegal immigrants still could buy insurance or sneak through, but that hardly supports a liar charge, does it?
Never mind that. Never mind that Wilson apologized that night.
Something bigger was at work.
A culture of confrontation
Hate breeds hate, anger breeds anger, and I have been arguing in this space for years now that the American discourse -- fueled by the Internet, talk radio and cable TV -- has turned so mean it has nowhere to go but get meaner. Little wonder that immediately after Wilson's unforgivable outburst, it was being justified by certain Republicans not because it was correct, but because Democrats had been equally insulting to Bush.
Hate breeds hate, and there is money and fame in yelling louder and angrier. You don't get on TV by asking thoughtful questions at a town hall meeting, but you sure can get there if you curse, holler and scream like a captured banshee. Come to think of it, that applies to TV hosts as well.
Is it any surprise such behavior eventually finds its way into a room with the president? We were abhorred when an Iraqi journalist threw his shoes at Bush. We called it barbaric, typical of a country hopelessly behind us on the civility scale.
Where does Wilson rank on that scale?
Clearly near the bottom. But why did he yell those two words? Why did that speech and this president cause a veteran politician like Wilson to lose control?
The right to actually lead
I have a theory. For all the fawning popularity Barack Obama enjoys in certain circles, he is equally vilified in others. Those who don't like him truly don't like him. And there seems to be an element in this country that doesn't want to accept him as the president. From the kooks hollering about his birth certificate to the paranoids insisting he is a closet Muslim, there are people who just don't want this guy in that office.
The fact that he is half-black is not wasted on them, either. Let's be blunt. Nobody can use the N-word in public anymore. But they can use socialist, anarchist, alien.
And somehow it's now acceptable to deem a guy who has been in office barely eight months unfit and unworthy. It's acceptable to suggest he's taking us straight to hell. It's acceptable to yell "You lie!" at the commander in chief in a place where it has never been yelled before.
Hate breeds hate. Two days ago, I boarded a plane heading for New York City. As we descended over the Manhattan skyline, I realized it was Sept. 11. I thought back to the emotions that followed that day eight years ago, a feeling of unity, a feeling a patriotism, a feeling that no enemy, no matter how evil or determined, could ever tear us apart.
The enemy doesn't have to. The way we are going, we'll do it ourselves.
For tickets to Mitch Albom's charity book launch for "Have a Little Faith" on Sept. 30 at the Fox Theatre, call 800-745-3000 or go to ticketmaster.com. Contact MITCH ALBOM: 313-223-4581 or malbom@freepress.com.
http://www.freep.com/article/20090913/COL01/909130431/1318/-You-lie---a-new-low--but-not-the-last&template=fullarticle
He said it well, but he misses a key point. The money angle isn't just one of attention, although both Wilson and his opponent have raised around a million dollars since the outburst (far more than their norm), but look where Wilson's money has come from in the past. His campaign donations have overwhelmingly come from the health care industry, insurance companies, drug companies, etc. Obama gained 14% approval for his plan in those who watched the speech. With two words, Wilson took the headlines away from him, nd no doubt pleased his own donors immensely.
ReplyDeleteMitch was right on. We don't respect one another anymore. Plain and simple. Have you ever seen the movie IDIOCRACY by Mike Judge? If you haven't, you should. Directing "You Lie" to the President of the United States is step one that will catapult us all into the world of IDIOCRACY if we're not careful.
ReplyDeleteMitch's new book, HAVE A LITTLE FAITH, deals loosely with this topic. In regards to faith uniting us rather than dividing us. He asks whether or not that will ever be possible. I really don't know. We - as a country - are SO divided. You on this side. Me on that side. We can't even seem to LISTEN to what someone on the other side has to say, let alone embrace it.
As Mitch states in his article, I hope that one day we can get back to the unity that we had after September 11th. We were a "team" back then. Fighting for one cause. Do you think we can ever get back there again?